Darvin wrote:... I used his Pacts. Not as often as I did consensus, but I really did.
Yeah, and I used Body Pact to prove that Paladins and Priests could beat (old) Naga City. For a while, I used it more than Consensus!
On your list, I mostly agree. Except I think that GG is a bit too high, since his limitations are quite obnoxious. He has similar space limitations to Taurog!
I also wasn't surprised to see Taurog at the bottom, but we've had that discussion in the past so I won't go into it again. I still prefer him to Binlor, Earthmother, and JJ. He's not so hot in most Vicious challenges, but he's one of the better PQI choices.